Youth Season 1 Review: Sharon Horgan Makes Midlife Chaos Funny, Messy, and Real

By Justin D. Williams
When I reviewed the first two episodes of HBO’s Youth, I said the series did a great job introducing us to Alex and the chaos surrounding her life. Now that Season 1 is complete, I think those opening episodes were an accurate representation of what the show ultimately became. Youth is funny, messy, uncomfortable, occasionally frustrating, and surprisingly emotional, but what impressed me most is how it takes what could have been a fairly standard midlife comedy and turns it into something much more thoughtful about getting older, parenthood, relationships, and the realization that reaching 50 doesn’t mean you suddenly have life figured out. Sharon Horgan stars as Alex, a divorced literary agent living in London who finds herself being pulled in almost every possible direction. Her son Ruari unexpectedly leaves university and moves back home at a point when Alex probably assumed that part of her parenting life was becoming a little easier. Her ex-husband Lorcan is moving forward with his own life, while Alex is also helping deal with aging parents who increasingly need more attention. At work, she is trying to prove herself under Sam, who is both her boss and one of her closest friends, and somewhere in the middle of all of that, Alex would still like to have a romantic and sexual life of her own.
That gives the season a lot to juggle, but I liked that Youth never presents Alex’s problems as one giant midlife crisis. She isn’t desperately trying to become 25 again, nor does the series suggest that turning 50 means she should gracefully accept that the exciting parts of her life are behind her. Alex wants sex, love, professional success and independence, but she is discovering that wanting those things while being responsible for so many other people can become complicated very quickly. The physical side of getting older is also handled with a refreshing level of honesty. Alex is dealing with menopause and changes to her body while simultaneously trying to feel desirable and comfortable with herself. There are some very funny moments that come from that, but the joke is rarely simply that Alex is an older woman. The show is much smarter than that. It allows her to be embarrassed, insecure, and confused about what her body is doing while still portraying her as someone with a healthy desire for intimacy. Horgan is fantastic at balancing all of those different versions of Alex. She can be completely confident at work and then become hilariously insecure about something in her personal life. She can give someone else sensible advice and then make an absolutely ridiculous decision herself ten minutes later. There are moments when I wanted Alex to stop, think, and save herself a whole lot of trouble, but that is part of why the character works. She isn't presented as the wise 50-year-old who has learned all of life's lessons. She is still learning them.
Her relationship with Patrick, played by Rupert Friend, becomes an important part of that journey. What starts as another piece of Alex attempting to rediscover herself gradually becomes something more substantial, and I liked that the series doesn't treat romance at this age as somehow less complicated than romance when you're younger. If anything, it can be more complicated because both people bring decades of experiences, expectations, and decisions with them. Friend and Horgan have great chemistry, but the relationship works because Patrick isn't simply written as Alex's reward for surviving divorce. Their connection forces Alex to think about what she actually wants from another person and what she is willing or unwilling to compromise at this point in her life. There are plenty of funny moments between them, but some of their strongest scenes come when Youth allows the humor to settle down and lets these two adults confront the reality that liking someone doesn't automatically eliminate every difference between them. As much as I enjoyed that relationship, the real heart of the season for me remained Alex and Ruari. I said in my premiere review that I loved Aran Murphy's acting while really disliking the character he was playing, and that feeling continued throughout much of the season. Murphy is extremely good at making Ruari irritating. He can be selfish, entitled, disrespectful and unbelievably frustrating, and there were numerous times when I wanted Alex to forget the gentle parenting, take his phone away and remind him exactly whose house he had moved back into.
But that reaction is also proof of how good Murphy is in the role. Ruari never feels like an actor trying to play an annoying young man. He feels like an actual young man who thinks he understands the world far better than he really does. Murphy gives him the attitude, awkwardness, and confidence of someone who desperately wants to be treated like an adult while repeatedly demonstrating that he still has a lot of growing up to do. What I appreciated even more as the season progressed is that Youth slowly adds context to Ruari without asking me to suddenly forget everything that annoyed me about him. There is insecurity underneath the attitude, and there is a young man trying to understand relationships, sex, masculinity, and what adulthood is supposed to look like without necessarily having the best examples around him. I could understand him more by the end of the season without suddenly thinking, “Oh, Ruari was right all along.” He wasn't, and sometimes he was still a pain in the ass. That complexity is much more interesting. It also creates an interesting parallel between mother and son. Ruari is supposed to be entering adulthood and has absolutely no idea what he is doing, while Alex has been an adult for decades and is discovering that she doesn't always know what she is doing either. They are at completely different stages of their lives, but both are essentially trying to answer the same question: what happens now?
That dynamic gives Horgan and Murphy some of the best material of the season. Their chemistry feels natural because their relationship isn't constantly sentimental. They argue, misunderstand each other, and know exactly how to irritate one another, but underneath all of that you believe that these two genuinely love each other. The season allows that relationship to change without suddenly fixing every issue between them, and I liked that because family relationships rarely work that neatly. The work storyline becomes more important than I initially expected as well. Alex isn't simply given a generic television job that exists whenever the plot needs somewhere else for her to be. Her career as a literary agent becomes another area where she is questioning whether she has accomplished enough and whether there is still room for her to achieve more. That also complicates her relationship with Sam. Sharlene Whyte does a great job because Sam exists in two parts of Alex's life at once: she is her friend, but she is also her boss. Those roles don't always coexist comfortably. Professional ambition, loyalty, and friendship begin running into each other, and I enjoyed that the series was willing to let two women who genuinely care about one another also become frustrated with each other. Their friendship doesn't exist simply so Sam can sit beside Alex with a glass of wine and listen to her complain about men.
The same applies to Alex's family. Her parents aren't there simply to remind us that she belongs to the sandwich generation. Caring for them adds another layer to a season that is constantly asking how much of yourself you can give to other people before wondering whether there is anything left for you. Alex is parenting someone who should be becoming independent while simultaneously watching her parents become more dependent, and that position between generations is one of the strongest ideas running through the season. If I have one criticism, it is that Youth occasionally has more interesting ideas than eight episodes can comfortably accommodate. Alex's romantic life, Ruari's problems, her parents, her ex-husband, Sam, the publishing world, and the supporting characters are all competing for time. Some characters and relationships could have benefited from another episode or two because there were moments when I wanted the series to stay with them longer instead of moving on to the next part of Alex's increasingly chaotic life.
At the same time, I would rather finish a season wanting more from these characters than feeling like the show stretched a thin premise beyond its limits. By the time Youth reaches its finale, many of Alex's different worlds begin colliding, and the season wisely avoids pretending that eight episodes are enough to solve every problem in her life. There are consequences to the choices characters have made, relationships that aren't tied into perfect bows, and questions that could easily continue into another season. What ultimately made Youth work for me is that the series understands something very simple: getting older doesn't necessarily make life less messy. Sometimes you're just dealing with a different kind of mess. Alex may be 50, but she is still capable of falling in love, making terrible decisions, worrying about her body, arguing with her parents, fighting with her friend, struggling professionally, and wondering whether she is doing a good job raising her son. Meanwhile, Ruari is standing at the opposite end of adulthood, thinking he knows far more than he does. Watching those two journeys unfold alongside one another gave the season much more emotional weight than I expected from the premise. Sharon Horgan carries the series beautifully, but Aran Murphy deserves just as much praise for making me dislike Ruari as much as I did while still keeping me interested in what happened to him. That is not an easy balance. If I genuinely wanted Alex to take that kid's phone away one moment and then found myself understanding where he was coming from later, Murphy was doing his job. Season 1 of Youth didn't completely change my opinion from those first two episodes. It strengthened it. What began as a great introduction to Alex's wonderfully complicated world became a funny and surprisingly honest examination of a woman discovering that there is still plenty of life left to figure out.
VIDEO REVIEW




Comments